Saturday, March 6, 2010

Will Liberals Show Up To Work?

With his announcement that the Liberal Party will vote against the budget, but not in significant number to defeat the legislation; Ignatieff must now instruct roughly 10 of his MPs to abstain from voting on the most important piece of legislation of the year. The budget has a greater direct impact on the lives of Canadians than any other bill on any other matter. The reason all budgets are election triggering confidence votes is because if the legislation is not passed, the Government can't function.

When I vote for an individual to represent me in the legislature, you can bet your ass that I expect them to cast a vote on the year's most important ballot. If it is good for me, I would like my representative to vote yes, and if it's bad for me I would like them to vote no. Abstaining is not an option. Stephane Dion already tried this strategy and it didn't work. I understand why they do it, because it's hard to complain about something they voted for. They want to retain the ability to complain about the budget, but in doing so they are exposing Canadians to something the Liberals are saying is bad for Canadians.

One could even make the claim that abstaining from what you believe to be a toxic budget vote is a form of Parliamentary depraved indifference. The Liberals are saying that this budget will have a strong negative impact on the lives of Canadians, but that they will not attempt to defeat the legislation despite having sufficient votes to do so. If you think prorogation erodes democracy, how can you support abstaining from legislation you are saying will harm your constituents?

It is nice to see that the grassroots Canadians Against Liberals Not Doing Their Jobs Facebook group, affectionately known as CALNDTJ is flourishing with 37 members in its first 24 hours. This is what dreams are made of. Regular people frustrated that the Opposition refuses to do their jobs. I have been "Tweeting" for 3 months and I have 20 Twitter followers. 37 in less than a day is astounding! There was one post on the site that I particularly liked.

"How big does this group have to grow before we can start chopping it down into regional chapters? Then we can start interfacing our Facebooks into our blackberries to invite each other to Liberal public speaking events to give the impression that flash mobs of spontaneous protests are magically popping up everywhere the Liberals speak. Then we can even start hosting our own public rallies and we can get the CBC to advertise relentlessly days in advance where the rallies will be, luring people with the promise of being on TV. Then when dozens of partisans show up, we can claim that there is a grassroots movement of people angry at the Liberal Party. That's how this works."

9 comments:

  1. What if the Liberals miscount and they are one MP too many and the government is defeated? What happens if they have counted right, but one Conservative MP happens to get stomach cramps and leaves before the vote?

    It shows the level of stupidity our opposition have descended to, vote against something but only enough to make sure they don't defeat the government. Make up your minds.

    This is way worse for our democracy than any prorogue will ever be. The Liberals/NDP/Bloc are spitting in the voters faces and telling them they should like it!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I suppose it is even plausible that the Liberals could attempt to accidently screw up their abstention and vote down a confidence motion. Iggy has to realize that the people on his team pushing the hardest for an election are the same people who want him replaced with Bob Rae.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The abstainers must be widely identified and campaigns against their re-elections started now

    ReplyDelete
  4. So what if they don't show up. They don't contribute anything to the governance of the country unless you count snide comments, innuendo, and whining.

    ReplyDelete
  5. How will the bloc vote?
    We already know Jack won't vote for it.
    I've been looking forward to the next election.

    And since when is a budget not a whipped vote?
    If the Liberals don't like it then they should vote against it.
    And be true to their principles.
    (See what I did there?)
    (I intimated that they have principles.)

    The budget will pass and the government will embark on the busiest legislative season we've ever seen.
    And then we'll have an election before the effects of the HST and the coming interest rate increases hit with full force.

    Early October election.

    ReplyDelete
  6. If iggy orders some of his mps to stay away or abstain, why can't they just cross the floor and sit on our side. We should have a poll or fb page, who will not vote against the budget, other than the conservatives. And, I agree with Hunter, they better count properly, remember Joe Clark.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hey MaryT - I think the CALNDTJ group on facebook will get a link to who voted for, against and abstentions. But I'm not smart enough to find out who beforehand...

    ReplyDelete
  8. What Powell said,
    So what if they don't show up.
    It's not like they do anything other than poke and run.

    Infact, the Government got more done when on prorogation than while sitting in the House.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The libs will show up if you hint at the possibility of plump, plain brown envelopes taped to the bottom of every second librano chair in H.O.C.

    TangoJuliette

    t.e.&o.e.

    ReplyDelete